The Upper Crust Menu
Introducing The Upper Crust, a culinary gem nestled in Gettysburg, PA, at 19 York St. This vibrant eatery specializes in wood-fired craft pizzas, offering bold flavors and a unique dining experience amidst a lively bar atmosphere. Patrons rave about the impeccable quality of dishes like the margarita pizza and the heavenly cheesesteak sub, often touted as the best in the area.
The expansive venue is perfect for groups, featuring arcade games for family fun and an inviting ambiance with open windows and outdoor seating. Though some may find the portion sizes a touch small for the price, the overall flavor and quality more than justify the visit. With friendly service and a diverse menu that includes BBQ delights from nearby partners, The Upper Crust ensures every visit is memorable. Whether for a casual meal or a special occasion, this spot is a must-try for both locals and visitors alike.
Food Menu - Wood-Fired Pizza Menu
The Margherita
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil.
The Sausage
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, spicy sausage, basil, and red chili flakes.
The Pepperoni
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, and mild, smooth thinly-sliced pepperoni.
The Sweet & Spicy
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, hot soppressata pork sausage, sweetened with a touch of spicy honey.
The Pineapple
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, pickled pineapple, pickled jalapeno, and bits of guanciale.
The Spinach
Baby spinach, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, goat cheese, herbs, and a balsamic reduction.
The Mushroom
Fresh mozzarella, fontina, pecorino, wild mushroom blend, herb mix, mushroom jus, and a farm fresh egg.
The Brisket
Slow-cooked brisket, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, fontina, pickled red onions, and house-made BBQ sauce.
The Arugula
Arugula, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, caramelized onion, and bits of guanciale.
The Four Cheese
Fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, fontina, with an herb mix and oven roasted garlic.
The Brussels And Bacon
Pecorino, mozzarella, ricotta, brussels sprout leaves, bacon marmalade, and EVOO.
The Smoked Chicken
Pecorino, mozzarella, fontina, smoked chicken, Mexican street corn, pickled jalapenos, chimichurri, and EVOO.
The Pulled Pork
Tomato sauce, pecorino, mozzarella, pulled pork oven-roasted peach salsa, and EVOO.
The Cheese
Upper Crust Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pecorino, fontina, and EVOO
The Meat
The Vegetable
Yukon Fries
Our house cut Yukon potatoes, seasoned and fried to perfection.
Light & Bright Salad
Bibb Lettuce, mixed greens, toasted pine nuts, fresh berries, pickled fennel, red wine dijon vinaigrette.
Hummus & Labneh
Wood-fired pita and roasted garlic chickpea hummus with middle-eastern spices.
Calamari
Battered and fried, charred lemon, served with spicy chipotle aioli.
Korean Spicy Wings
Eight fried chicken wings tossed in our special Korean sauce, topped with toasted sesame seeds
Czech Pierogies
Made from a family heirloom recipe, our potato and cheese pierogies are fried and served with your choice of sour cream or sauerkraut
Roasted Cauliflower
Oven-roasted cauliflower, pistachio pesto, and garlic bread crumbs.
Pretzel Mac & Cheese
Fresh pasta, gouda, cheddar, and monterey jack tossed in pretzel crumbs and fried, with honey mustard sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded and fried mozzarella with Upper Crust marinara sauce.
Middle Eastern Salad
Romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, garlic, lemon-za’atar dressing.
House Made Syrian Bread/Pita
Food Menu - Appetizers
Food Menu - Sandwich Menu
Syrian Shawarma
Hand-carved rotisserie lamb and beef wrapped in a warm, wood-fired pita with our house-made cucumber yogurt dressing, lettuce, tomato, and onions
The Cheesesteak
Marinated steak and melted cheese in a toasted roll with your choice of fried onions, peppers, mushrooms, pickles, jalapenos, or pickled red onions
The Burger
4oz Angus beef, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and a side of chipotle aioli on toasted Brioche.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, topped with bleu cheese crumbles, lettuce, and tomato on toasted brioche, and served with our seasoned fries.
The Cold Cut
The Margherita
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil.
The Sausage
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, spicy sausage, basil, and red chili flakes.
The Pepperoni
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, and mild, smooth thinly-sliced pepperoni.
The Sweet & Spicy
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, hot soppressata pork sausage, sweetened with a touch of spicy honey.
The Pineapple
Upper Crust tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, pickled pineapple, pickled jalapeno, and bits of guanciale.
The Spinach
Baby spinach, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, goat cheese, herbs, and a balsamic reduction.
The Mushroom
Fresh mozzarella, fontina, pecorino, wild mushroom blend, herb mix, mushroom jus, and a farm fresh egg.
The Brisket
Slow-cooked brisket, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, fontina, pickled red onions, and house-made BBQ sauce.
The Arugula
Arugula, fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, caramelized onion, and bits of guanciale.
The Four Cheese
Fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, ricotta cheese, fontina, with an herb mix and oven roasted garlic.
The Brussels And Bacon
Pecorino, mozzarella, ricotta, brussels sprout leaves, bacon marmalade, and EVOO.
The Smoked Chicken
Pecorino, mozzarella, fontina, smoked chicken, Mexican street corn, pickled jalapenos, chimichurri, and EVOO.
The Pulled Pork
Tomato sauce, pecorino, mozzarella, pulled pork oven-roasted peach salsa, and EVOO.
The Cheese
Upper Crust Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pecorino, fontina, and EVOO
The Meat
The Vegetable
Wood-Fired Pizza Menu
Appetizers
Yukon Fries
Our house cut Yukon potatoes, seasoned and fried to perfection.
Light & Bright Salad
Bibb Lettuce, mixed greens, toasted pine nuts, fresh berries, pickled fennel, red wine dijon vinaigrette.
Hummus & Labneh
Wood-fired pita and roasted garlic chickpea hummus with middle-eastern spices.
Calamari
Battered and fried, charred lemon, served with spicy chipotle aioli.
Korean Spicy Wings
Eight fried chicken wings tossed in our special Korean sauce, topped with toasted sesame seeds
Czech Pierogies
Made from a family heirloom recipe, our potato and cheese pierogies are fried and served with your choice of sour cream or sauerkraut
Roasted Cauliflower
Oven-roasted cauliflower, pistachio pesto, and garlic bread crumbs.
Pretzel Mac & Cheese
Fresh pasta, gouda, cheddar, and monterey jack tossed in pretzel crumbs and fried, with honey mustard sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded and fried mozzarella with Upper Crust marinara sauce.
Middle Eastern Salad
Romaine, tomato, cucumber, red onion, garlic, lemon-za’atar dressing.
House Made Syrian Bread/Pita
Borough Fries
Hand-cut, lightly sprinkled with our special blend of seasoning.
Borough Wings
Eight wings tossed with your choice of our signature sauces.
Corn Fritters
Served with powdered sugar and hot honey.
Fried Green Tomatoes
Served with smokey tomato BBQ sauce.
Hush Puppies
Served with sweet and spicy chipotle drizzle.
Onion Rings
Crispy Battered Onions Served with horseradish dill sauce.
Syrian Shawarma
Hand-carved rotisserie lamb and beef wrapped in a warm, wood-fired pita with our house-made cucumber yogurt dressing, lettuce, tomato, and onions
The Cheesesteak
Marinated steak and melted cheese in a toasted roll with your choice of fried onions, peppers, mushrooms, pickles, jalapenos, or pickled red onions
The Burger
4oz Angus beef, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and a side of chipotle aioli on toasted Brioche.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, topped with bleu cheese crumbles, lettuce, and tomato on toasted brioche, and served with our seasoned fries.
The Cold Cut
Sandwich Menu
Borough BBQ - Food - Appetizers
Borough Fries
Hand-cut, lightly sprinkled with our special blend of seasoning.
Borough Wings
Eight wings tossed with your choice of our signature sauces.
Corn Fritters
Served with powdered sugar and hot honey.
Fried Green Tomatoes
Served with smokey tomato BBQ sauce.
Hush Puppies
Served with sweet and spicy chipotle drizzle.
Onion Rings
Crispy Battered Onions Served with horseradish dill sauce.
Mac & Cheese
Creamy and savory pasta with gouda, cheddar, and colby jack, topped with dry rub.
Coleslaw
Creamy fresh cabbage and carrots.
Cornbread
Served with cinnamon honey butter.
Baked Beans
Hickory-smoked maple bacon and roasted peaches.
Brussel Sprouts
Fried and topped with a honey dijon drizzle.
Red Skin Potato Salad
Chopped red skin potatoes and diced hard-boiled eggs in a zesty dressing.
Borough BBQ - Food - Sides
Borough BBQ - Food - Entrees
Prime Beef Brisket
Carved to order, tender and juicy sliced brisket. With your choice of two sauces.
Half Smoked Chicken
Smoked daily, savory and rich BBQ chicken. Your choice of two sauces.
Whole Smoked Chicken
Smoked daily, savory and rich BBQ chicken. Your choice of two sauces.
Half Rack Ribs
Our competition-style pork ribs, with generous smoke and seasoning. Your choice of two sauces.
Full Rack Ribs
Our competition-style pork ribs, with generous smoke and seasoning. Your choice of two sauces.
Fish & Chips
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Low and slow pulled pork, with coleslaw, mustard vinegar sauce on toasted brioche.
BBQ Brisket Sandwich
Slow-smoked brisket, coleslaw, sweet and tangy sauce, on tasted brioche.
Sausage Sandwich
Borough BBQ - Food - Sandwiches
Borough BBQ - Appetizers
Borough Fries
Hand-cut, lightly sprinkled with our special blend of seasoning.
Borough Wings
Eight wings tossed with your choice of our signature sauces.
Corn Fritters
Served with powdered sugar and hot honey.
Fried Green Tomatoes
Served with smokey tomato BBQ sauce.
Hush Puppies
Served with sweet and spicy chipotle drizzle.
Onion Rings
Crispy Battered Onions Served with horseradish dill sauce.
Mac & Cheese
Creamy and savory pasta with gouda, cheddar, and colby jack, topped with dry rub.
Coleslaw
Creamy fresh cabbage and carrots.
Cornbread
Served with cinnamon honey butter.
Baked Beans
Hickory-smoked maple bacon and roasted peaches.
Brussel Sprouts
Fried and topped with a honey dijon drizzle.
Red Skin Potato Salad
Chopped red skin potatoes and diced hard-boiled eggs in a zesty dressing.
Borough BBQ - Sides
Borough BBQ - Entrees
Prime Beef Brisket
Carved to order, tender and juicy sliced brisket. With your choice of two sauces.
Half Smoked Chicken
Smoked daily, savory and rich BBQ chicken. Your choice of two sauces.
Whole Smoked Chicken
Smoked daily, savory and rich BBQ chicken. Your choice of two sauces.
Half Rack Ribs
Our competition-style pork ribs, with generous smoke and seasoning. Your choice of two sauces.
Full Rack Ribs
Our competition-style pork ribs, with generous smoke and seasoning. Your choice of two sauces.
Fish & Chips
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Low and slow pulled pork, with coleslaw, mustard vinegar sauce on toasted brioche.
BBQ Brisket Sandwich
Slow-smoked brisket, coleslaw, sweet and tangy sauce, on tasted brioche.
Sausage Sandwich
Borough BBQ - Sandwiches
Food - Appetizers
Borough Fries
Hand-cut, lightly sprinkled with our special blend of seasoning.
Borough Wings
Eight wings tossed with your choice of our signature sauces.
Corn Fritters
Served with powdered sugar and hot honey.
Fried Green Tomatoes
Served with smokey tomato BBQ sauce.
Hush Puppies
Served with sweet and spicy chipotle drizzle.
Onion Rings
Crispy Battered Onions Served with horseradish dill sauce.
Mac & Cheese
Creamy and savory pasta with gouda, cheddar, and colby jack, topped with dry rub.
Coleslaw
Creamy fresh cabbage and carrots.
Cornbread
Served with cinnamon honey butter.
Baked Beans
Hickory-smoked maple bacon and roasted peaches.
Brussel Sprouts
Fried and topped with a honey dijon drizzle.
Red Skin Potato Salad
Chopped red skin potatoes and diced hard-boiled eggs in a zesty dressing.
Food - Sides
Food - Entrees
Prime Beef Brisket
Carved to order, tender and juicy sliced brisket. With your choice of two sauces.
Half Smoked Chicken
Smoked daily, savory and rich BBQ chicken. Your choice of two sauces.
Whole Smoked Chicken
Smoked daily, savory and rich BBQ chicken. Your choice of two sauces.
Half Rack Ribs
Our competition-style pork ribs, with generous smoke and seasoning. Your choice of two sauces.
Full Rack Ribs
Our competition-style pork ribs, with generous smoke and seasoning. Your choice of two sauces.
Fish & Chips
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Low and slow pulled pork, with coleslaw, mustard vinegar sauce on toasted brioche.
BBQ Brisket Sandwich
Slow-smoked brisket, coleslaw, sweet and tangy sauce, on tasted brioche.
Sausage Sandwich
Food - Sandwiches
Sides
Mac & Cheese
Creamy and savory pasta with gouda, cheddar, and colby jack, topped with dry rub.
Coleslaw
Creamy fresh cabbage and carrots.
Cornbread
Served with cinnamon honey butter.
Baked Beans
Hickory-smoked maple bacon and roasted peaches.
Brussel Sprouts
Fried and topped with a honey dijon drizzle.
Red Skin Potato Salad
Chopped red skin potatoes and diced hard-boiled eggs in a zesty dressing.
Prime Beef Brisket
Carved to order, tender and juicy sliced brisket. With your choice of two sauces.
Half Smoked Chicken
Smoked daily, savory and rich BBQ chicken. Your choice of two sauces.
Whole Smoked Chicken
Smoked daily, savory and rich BBQ chicken. Your choice of two sauces.
Half Rack Ribs
Our competition-style pork ribs, with generous smoke and seasoning. Your choice of two sauces.
Full Rack Ribs
Our competition-style pork ribs, with generous smoke and seasoning. Your choice of two sauces.
Fish & Chips
Entrees
Sandwiches
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Low and slow pulled pork, with coleslaw, mustard vinegar sauce on toasted brioche.
BBQ Brisket Sandwich
Slow-smoked brisket, coleslaw, sweet and tangy sauce, on tasted brioche.